Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Meghan Bell's avatar

I've been wondering about this phenomenon. When I first saw the aphantasia/hyperphantasia memes, I leaned toward identifying myself as having "hyperphantasia." This is because I had a vivid imagination as a child, and could easily dissociate into daydreams, and because I test as extremely gifted on tests of spatial rotation (I was given a test as a kid where you're shown how a piece of paper is folded, then holes and shapes are cut out of the folded paper and you have to choose which design the paper would have once it's unfolded -- I got a perfect score and honestly was confused that other people might find this challenging). I'm insanely good at Tetris (including the 3D variation available on VR headsets, SuperHyperCube, which involves rotating increasingly complex 3D shapes to fit through a hole in a wall). I'm difficult to beat at Boggle because I don't have to look at the board as much as most people; I look at an area of the board, remember it, and quickly find anagrams in my head and quickly write them down.

But I don't literally "see" things with my mind's eye. I mean, I "see" them, but not the same way I see, for example, closed-eye fractals on a psychedelics trip. I've wondered if I only identified with "hyperphantasia" because I didn't take it literally as "seeing" something, but more metaphorically. If I were to answer whether I literally see something, I'd answer "no" -- aphantasia.

I honestly don't know, but I'm confused.

I can draw objects fairly well from memory, but have some motor clumsiness (from a traumatic brain injury to the right parietal lobe). I'm often frustrated my hand can't produce what my "inner eye" wants it to.

Similarly, I can "hear" full songs in my head, but I don't literally "hear" them. Once on ketamine I actually hallucinated a song playing (heard it with my ears, not just my brain) and that was very different.

Expand full comment
ThinkPieceOfPie's avatar

I'm a 5. I can replay a movie in my head. I can imagine the past, smells, tactile stuff, everything. It's shocking to ME that not everyone can do this. I feel lucky, but it's not all good--I mean, I like remembering the happy times, but...

Anyway, I have a question for you #1-2 people--what about audio? can you imagine sounds, play a song in your head?

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts